Okay, parents. Raise your hand if you’ve ever stolen your kids’ Halloween candy. We see you. 👀

The BFI (Butterfinger Investigators) are on the case with a campaign encouraging Butterfinger thieves (aka parents) to turn themselves in to the BFI for a cash reward. A reward for stealing? Seems counterintuitive, but who are we to get in the way of a $25,000 cash prize.

Related: Party City is Helping ‘You Boo You’ Safely This Halloween

Candy thieves can turn themselves in by visiting the BFI HQ at butterfingercasefiles.com and signing a digital “confession” to enter the sweepstakes. Share the confession on Facebook and Twitter for additional entries.

The sweepstakes ends on Nov. 6, giving you plenty of time to steal all of that leftover Halloween candy while it’s still fresh.